Unknown. Advisory opinion

5,250 words·~24 min read·/register/2022/07/05/2022-14230·

A research copy — for the controlling text, always check the official state or federal source. Not legal advice.

--- schema: federal-register doc_type: fedreg source_file: FR-2022-07-05.xml --- 87 127 Tuesday, July 5, 2022 Contents Administrative Administrative Conference of the United States NOTICES Adoption of Recommendations, 39798-39802 2022-14189 AIRFORCE Air Force Department NOTICES Environmental Impact Statements; Availability, etc.: T-7A Recapitalization at Joint Base San Antonio-Randolph, TX, 39808 2022-14243 Consumer Financial Protection Bureau of Consumer Financial Protection RULES Debt Collection Practices (Regulation F):

Pay-to-Pay Fees, 39733-39735 2022-14230 Centers Disease Centers for Disease Control and Prevention NOTICES Agency Information Collection Activities; Proposals, Submissions, and Approvals, 39837-39840 2022-14213 2022-14218 Request for Information: Manufacturers of Platforms for Nucleic Acid Amplification or Detection Suitable for Assay Development and Molecular Diagnostics for Detection of Agents That Cause Infectious Diseases, 39836-39837 2022-14211 Civil Rights Civil Rights Commission NOTICES Meetings;

Sunshine Act, 39802-39803 2022-14382 Coast Guard Coast Guard RULES Special Local Regulation: Ohio River, Marietta, OH, 39748-39750 2022-14223 NOTICES Agency Information Collection Activities; Proposals, Submissions, and Approvals, 39845-39847 2022-14249 2022-14248 Commerce Commerce Department See International Trade Administration See National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration Comptroller Comptroller of the Currency PROPOSED RULES Community Reinvestment Act, 39792 C1-2022-10111 Defense Department Defense Department See Air Force Department Education Department Education Department NOTICES 2022-2023 Award Year Deadline Dates for Reports and Other Records:

Free Application for Federal Student Aid, Federal Supplemental Educational Opportunity Grant Program, Federal Work-Study Program, etc.; Correction, 39809 2022-14193 Agency Information Collection Activities; Proposals, Submissions, and Approvals: Randolph-Sheppard Financial Relief and Restoration Payments Appropriation Final Performance Report, 39809-39810 2022-14273 Supporting Excellence in Adult Education, 39810 2022-14175 Energy Department Energy Department See Federal Energy Regulatory Commission NOTICES Meetings:

Secretary of Energy Advisory Board, 39811-39812 2022-14209 Reimbursement for Costs of Remedial Action at Uranium and Thorium Processing Sites, 39810-39811 2022-14208 Environmental Protection Environmental Protection Agency RULES Air Quality State Implementation Plans; Approvals and Promulgations: Indiana; Redesignation of the Indiana Portion of the Louisville, IN-KY Area to Attainment of the 2015 Ozone Standards, 39750-39752 2022-14202 Pesticide Tolerance; Exemptions, Petitions, Revocations, etc.:

Pyriofenone, 39752-39756 2022-14224 Significant New Uses of Chemical Substances: Updates to the Hazard Communication Program and Regulatory Framework; Minor Amendments to Reporting Requirements for Premanufacture Notices, 39756-39769 2022-13324 NOTICES Agency Information Collection Activities; Proposals, Submissions, and Approvals: Criteria for Classification of Solid Waste Disposal Facilities and Practices, 39830-39831 2022-14219 Pesticide Registration Review: Atrazine; Proposed Revisions to the Interim Registration Review Decision Memorandum, 39822-39824 2022-14255 Proposed Consent Decree:

Clean Air Act Citizen Suit, 39821-39822 2022-14220 Risk Evaluations for Chemical Substances, 39824-39830 2022-14163 Federal Aviation Federal Aviation Administration RULES Airspace Designations and Reporting Points: Vicinity of Samsville, IL, 39745-39746 2022-14199 Airworthiness Directives: Airbus SAS Airplanes, 39735-39738, 39741-39745 2022-14194 2022-14195 2022-14196 Williams International Co., LLC Turbofan Engines, 39738-39741 2022-14183 Colo Void Clause Coalition; Antenna Systems Co-Location;

Voluntary Best Practices, 39746-39748 2022-14306 NOTICES Agency Information Collection Activities; Proposals, Submissions, and Approvals: Training and Qualification Requirements for Check Airmen and Flight Instructors, 39887 2022-14250 Federal Communications Federal Communications Commission RULES Review of Rules and Requirements for Priority Services, 39770-39790 2022-14155 Television Broadcasting Services: Medford, OR, 39790-39791 2022-14201 Federal Deposit Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation PROPOSED RULES Community Reinvestment Act, 39792 C1-2022-10111 Federal Emergency Federal Emergency Management Agency NOTICES Changes in Flood Hazard Determinations;

Correction, 39851 2022-14266 Flood Hazard Determinations, 39849-39854 2022-14267 2022-14269 Proposed Flood Hazard Determinations, 39848-39849 2022-14268 Federal Energy Federal Energy Regulatory Commission PROPOSED RULES Improvements to Generator Interconnection Procedures and Agreements, 39934-40032 2022-13470 NOTICES Agency Information Collection Activities; Proposals, Submissions, and Approvals, 39814-39815 2022-14234 Application: Dominion Energy South Carolina, Inc., 39815-39816 2022-14233 Lower Saranac Hydro, LLC;

Denial of Water Quality Certification, 39820 2022-14232 West Texas Gas, Inc., West Texas Gas Utility, LLC, 39812-39814 2022-14236 Combined Filings, 39815-39820 2022-14166 2022-14173 2022-14221 2022-14222 Initial Market-Based Rate Filings Including Requests for Blanket Section 204 Authorizations: EDPR CA Solar Park II LLC, 39818 2022-14168 EDPR CA Solar Park, LLC, 39819 2022-14169 EDPR Scarlet I LLC, 39818 2022-14167 Northwest Ohio IA, LLC, 39820-39821 2022-14170 Northwest Ohio Solar, LLC, 39812 2022-14171 Shared Facilities Agreement and Certificate of Concurrence Filing That Includes Request for Blanket Section 204 Authorization:

Deerfield Wind Energy 2, LLC, Deerfield Wind Energy, LLC, 39821 2022-14235 Federal Highway Federal Highway Administration NOTICES Revision of Form FHWA-1273, 39887-39889 2022-14256 Federal Motor Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration NOTICES Exemption Application: Qualification of Drivers; Implantable Cardioverter Defibrillator, 39891-39894 2022-14225 2022-14226 Qualification of Drivers; Exemption Applications: Epilepsy and Seizure Disorders, 39889-39891 2022-14227 Federal Railroad Federal Railroad Administration NOTICES Agency Information Collection Activities;

Proposals, Submissions, and Approvals, 39894-39898 2022-14188 2022-14244 Federal Reserve Federal Reserve System PROPOSED RULES Community Reinvestment Act, 39792 C1-2022-10111 NOTICES Agency Information Collection Activities; Proposals, Submissions, and Approvals, 39831-39833 2022-14216 2022-14217 Formations of, Acquisitions by, and Mergers of Bank Holding Companies, 39832-39833 2022-14253 Federal Trade Federal Trade Commission NOTICES Analysis of Proposed Consent Order: Harley-Davidson Motor Company Group, LLC, 39833-39835 2022-14178 Fish Fish and Wildlife Service NOTICES Incidental Take Permit Application and Proposed Habitat Conservation Plan:

Audubon's Crested Caracara; Glades County, FL; Categorical Exclusion, 39865 2022-14182 Permits; Applications, Issuances, etc.: Endangered and Threatened Species; Enhancement of Survival and Incidental Take Permits for Safe Harbor Agreements, Candidate Conservation Agreements, etc., 2021, 39855-39864 2022-14203 Foreign Assets Foreign Assets Control Office NOTICES Sanctions Actions, 39901-39930 2022-14210 General Services General Services Administration NOTICES Agency Information Collection Activities;

Proposals, Submissions, and Approvals: Construction Contract Administration, 39836 2022-14187 Federal Management Regulation: Designation of a Federal Building, 39836 2022-14238 Midyear Adjustment to the Calendar Year 2022 Privately Owned Vehicle Mileage Reimbursement Rates and Standard Mileage Rate for Moving Purposes (Relocation Allowances), 39835-39836 2022-14264 Health and Human Health and Human Services Department See Centers for Disease Control and Prevention See Health Resources and Services Administration See National Institutes of Health See Substance Abuse and Mental Health Services Administration NOTICES Meetings:

National Committee on Vital and Health Statistics, 39842-39843 2022-14176 Health Resources Health Resources and Services Administration NOTICES Agency Information Collection Activities; Proposals, Submissions, and Approvals: Evaluation of the Maternal and Child Health Bureau Pediatric Mental Health Care Access Program and the Screening and Treatment for Maternal Depression and Related Behavioral Disorders Program, 39841-39842 2022-14184 Homeland Homeland Security Department See Coast Guard See Federal Emergency Management Agency See Transportation Security Administration See U.S.

Customs and Border Protection Indian Affairs Indian Affairs Bureau NOTICES Indian Gaming: Approval of Tribal-State Class III Gaming Compact Amendment Between Nisqually Indian Tribe and the State of Washington, 39866 2022-14351 Interior Interior Department See Fish and Wildlife Service See Indian Affairs Bureau See Land Management Bureau See National Park Service International Trade Adm International Trade Administration NOTICES Binational Panel Review: North American Free Trade Agreement;

Panel Decision, 39803 2022-14174 International Trade Com International Trade Commission NOTICES Agency Information Collection Activities; Proposals, Submissions, and Approvals: Foreign Trade Zones: Effects of FTZ Policies and Practices on U.S. Firms Operating in U.S. FTZs and Under Similar Programs in Canada and Mexico, 39869-39870 2022-14272 Investigations; Determinations, Modifications, and Rulings, etc.: Certain Light-Emitting Diode Products, Fixtures, and Components Thereof, 39870-39871 2022-14270 Helical Spring Lock Washers From China and Taiwan, 39869 2022-14265 Labor Department Labor Department NOTICES Agency Information Collection Activities;

Proposals, Submissions, and Approvals: Attestation for Employers Seeking To Employ H-2B Nonimmigrant Workers, 39871-39872 2022-14206 Land Land Management Bureau NOTICES Recreation Fees on Public Lands: Price, Richfield, and Salt Lake Field Offices, UT, 39866-39868 2022-14251 Segregation of Public Land: Golden Currant Solar Project, Clark County, NV, 39866 2022-14254 NASA National Aeronautics and Space Administration NOTICES Meetings: Aerospace Safety Advisory Panel, 39872 2022-14200 National Archives National Archives and Records Administration NOTICES Records Schedules, 39872-39873 2022-14247 National Endowment for the Humanities National Endowment for the Humanities NOTICES Meetings:

National Council on the Humanities, 39873 2022-14179 National Foundation National Foundation on the Arts and the Humanities See National Endowment for the Humanities National Highway National Highway Traffic Safety Administration NOTICES Creation of the Model Minimum Uniform Crash Criteria Committee, 39898-39899 2022-14240 Denial of Motor Vehicle Defect Petition, 39899-39901 2022-14165 National Institute National Institutes of Health NOTICES Meetings: Center for Scientific Review, 39843-39844 2022-14262 Eunice Kennedy Shriver National Institute of Child Health and Human Development, 39843-39844 2022-14260 2022-14263 National Heart, Lung, and Blood Institute, 39843 2022-14261 National Oceanic National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration PROPOSED RULES Fisheries Off West Coast States:

Pacific Coast Groundfish Fishery; Non-Trawl Logbook, 39792-39797 2022-14295 NOTICES Agency Information Collection Activities; Proposals, Submissions, and Approvals: National Sea Turtle Stranding and Salvage Network Stranding and Gear Interaction Data Collection, 39806-39807 2022-14180 Endangered and Threatened Species: Take of Steelhead; Take of Green Sturgeon, 39807-39808 2022-14204 Environmental Impact Statements; Availability, etc.: Makah Tribe's Request To Hunt Eastern North Pacific Gray Whales, 39804-39805 2022-14245 Meetings:

Caribbean Fishery Management Council, 39804 2022-14257 Mid-Atlantic Fishery Management Council, 39805-39807 2022-14258 2022-14259 Permits; Applications, Issuances, etc.: Marine Mammals; File No. 26591, 39803 2022-14205 National Park National Park Service NOTICES National Register of Historic Places: Pending Nominations and Related Actions, 39868-39869 2022-14215 National Science National Science Foundation NOTICES Charter Amendments, Establishments, Renewals and Terminations:

Advisory Committees, 39874 2022-14252 Nuclear Regulatory Nuclear Regulatory Commission NOTICES Fiscal Years 2023-2027 Artificial Intelligence Strategic Plan, 39874-39876 2022-14239 Meetings; Sunshine Act, 39874 2022-14365 Postal Regulatory Postal Regulatory Commission NOTICES Meetings; Sunshine Act, 39876 2022-14324 Postal Service Postal Service NOTICES Privacy Act; Systems of Records, 39876-39880 2022-14277 Securities Securities and Exchange Commission NOTICES Self-Regulatory Organizations;

Proposed Rule Changes: BOX Exchange, LLC, 39880-39884 2022-14177 Small Business Small Business Administration PROPOSED RULES Small Business Size Standards: Adoption of North American Industry Classification System for Size Standards, 40034-40087 2022-13250 NOTICES Meetings: Council on Underserved Communities, 39884 2022-14172 Social Social Security Administration NOTICES Privacy Act; Matching Program, 39884-39886 2022-14231 State Department State Department NOTICES Culturally Significant Object Being Imported for Exhibition:

First Kings of Europe: The Emergence of Hierarchy in the Prehistoric Balkans, 39886 2022-14229 Jannis Kounellis in Six Acts, 39886-39887 2022-14228 Waivers Extensions: Freedom Support Act With Respect to Assistance to the Government of Azerbaijan, 39886 2022-14190 Substance Substance Abuse and Mental Health Services Administration NOTICES Meetings: National Advisory Council, 39844-39845 2022-14242 Transportation Department Transportation Department See Federal Aviation Administration See Federal Highway Administration See Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration See Federal Railroad Administration See National Highway Traffic Safety Administration Security Transportation Security Administration NOTICES Agency Information Collection Activities;

Proposals, Submissions, and Approvals: Law Enforcement Officers Flying Armed, 39854 2022-14275 Treasury Treasury Department See Comptroller of the Currency See Foreign Assets Control Office NOTICES Agency Information Collection Activities; Proposals, Submissions, and Approvals: Primary Dealer Meeting Agenda, 39930-39931 2022-14185 List of Countries Requiring Cooperation With an International Boycott, 39931 2022-14192 Customs U.S. Customs and Border Protection NOTICES Quarterly Interest Rates Used in Calculating Interest on Overdue Accounts and Refunds on Custom Duties, 39847-39848 2022-14207 Separate Parts In This Issue Part II Energy Department, Federal Energy Regulatory Commission, 39934-40032 2022-13470 Part III Small Business Administration, 40034-40087 2022-13250 Reader Aids Consult the Reader Aids section at the end of this issue for phone numbers, online resources, finding aids, and notice of recently enacted public laws.

To subscribe to the Federal Register Table of Contents electronic mailing list, go to https://public.govdelivery.com/accounts/USGPOOFR/subscriber/new, enter your e-mail address, then follow the instructions to join, leave, or manage your subscription. 87 127 Tuesday, July 5, 2022 Rules and Regulations BUREAU OF CONSUMER FINANCIAL PROTECTION 12 CFR Part 1006 Debt Collection Practices (Regulation F); Pay-to-Pay Fees AGENCY: Bureau of Consumer Financial Protection. ACTION: Advisory opinion.

SUMMARY: Section 808(1) of the Fair Debt Collection Practices Act (FDCPA or Act) prohibits debt collectors from collecting any amount (including any interest, fee, charge, or expense incidental to the principal obligation) unless that amount is expressly authorized by the agreement creating the debt or permitted by law. The Consumer Financial Protection Bureau

(CFPB)issues this advisory opinion to affirm that this provision prohibits debt collectors from collecting pay-to-pay or “convenience” fees, such as fees imposed for making a payment online or by phone, when those fees are not expressly authorized by the agreement creating the debt or expressly authorized by law. This advisory opinion also clarifies that a debt collector may also violate section 808(1) when the debt collector collects pay-to-pay fees through a third-party payment processor. DATES: This advisory opinion is effective on July 5, 2022. FOR FURTHER INFORMATION CONTACT: Sonya Pass, Senior Legal Counsel and Chief of Staff, Legal Division,

(202)435-7700. If you require this document in an alternative electronic format, please contact *CFPB_Accessibility@cfpb.gov.* SUPPLEMENTARY INFORMATION: I. Advisory Opinion A. Background Congress enacted the FDCPA in 1977 to “eliminate abusive debt collection practices by debt collectors, to insure that those debt collectors who refrain from using abusive debt collection practices are not competitively disadvantaged, and to promote consistent State action to protect consumers against debt collection abuses.” 1 The statute was a response to “abundant evidence of the use of abusive, deceptive, and unfair debt collection practices by many debt collectors,” which Congress attributed to the “inadequacy” of “existing laws and procedures,” including State laws. 2 To remedy this, the FDCPA imposes various requirements and restrictions on debt collectors' debt collection activity. Relevant here is section 808, which provides that a “debt collector may not use unfair or unconscionable means to collect or attempt to collect any debt.” 3 Section 808 then states that “[w]ithout limiting the general application of the foregoing, the following conduct is a violation of this section” and enumerates eight specifically prohibited practices, including the “collection of any amount (including any interest, fee, charge, or expense incidental to the principal obligation) unless such amount is expressly authorized by the agreement creating the debt or permitted by law.” 4 1 Public Law 95-109, sec. 802(e), 91 Stat. 874, 874 (codified at 15 U.S.C. 1692(e)). 2 15 U.S.C. 1692(a), (b). *See also* S. Rep. No. 95-382, at 2

(1977)(stating that “debt collection abuse by third party debt collectors [was] a widespread and serious national problem,” which Congress largely attributed to a “lack of meaningful legislation on the State level”). 3 15 U.S.C. 1692f. 4 15 U.S.C. 1692f(1). At the time of the FDCPA's enactment, the Federal Trade Commission

(FTC)was the agency that administered, and had primary responsibility for enforcing, the FDCPA. 5 Then, in 2010, Congress passed the Dodd-Frank Wall Street Reform and Consumer Protection Act, which created the CFPB and granted it authority to administer, implement, and enforce the FDCPA. 6 Congress also provided the CFPB authority to prescribe rules under the FDCPA. 7 Pursuant to that authority, in 2020, the CFPB issued Regulation F, which implements the FDCPA, to prescribe rules governing the activities of debt collectors. 8 The CFPB implemented FDCPA section 808(1) at 12 CFR 1006.22(b) by “generally mirror[ing] the statute, with minor wording and organizational changes for clarity.” 9 In particular, the CFPB stated that the “term `any amount' includes any interest, fee, charge, or expense incidental to the principal obligation.” 10 5 *See* 15 U.S.C. 1692 *l*

(a)(2010). 6 Public Law 111-203, sec. 1089, 124 Stat. 1376, 2093 (codified at 15 U.S.C. 1692 *l* (b)(6)). 7 15 U.S.C. 1691 *l* (d). 8 *See* Debt Collection Practices (Regulation F), 85 FR 76734 (Nov. 30, 2020); Debt Collection Practices (Regulation F), 86 FR 5766 (Jan. 19, 2021). 9 85 FR 76734, 76833. 10 *Id.* at 76833, 76892. In 2013, the CFPB launched its supervisory program over certain larger participants in the consumer debt collection market. Through these examinations, the CFPB ascertains compliance with the FDCPA, and now Regulation F, as well as other Federal consumer financial laws. The CFPB also periodically publishes *Supervisory Highlights* with anonymized findings and analysis from these supervisory examinations, as well as compliance bulletins to provide entities with guidance on complying with certain legal requirements. For example, in 2017, the CFPB issued a compliance bulletin (Bulletin) that “provides guidance to debt collectors about compliance with the [FDCPA] when assessing phone pay fees,” a type of pay-to-pay fee. 11 The Bulletin summarizes CFPB staff's conclusion that, under section 808(1), debt collectors may collect such pay-to-pay fees only if the underlying contract or state law expressly authorizes those fees. 12 In particular, the Bulletin states that in at least one supervisory exam, CFPB examiners found that a debt collector “violated [section 808(1)] when they charged fees for taking mortgage payments over the phone” where the underlying contracts creating the debt did not expressly authorize collecting such fees and where the relevant State law did not “expressly permit collecting such fees.” 13 11 CFPB Compliance Bulletin 2017-01, 82 FR 35936, 35936 (Aug. 2, 2017). 12 *Id.* at 35938. 13 *Id.* (explaining that the CFPB examiners had instructed the company to collect pay-by-phone fees only “where expressly authorized by contract or state law”); *see also* CFPB: Fall 2014 Supervisory Highlights, at 7, *available at https://files.consumerfinance.gov/f/201410_cfpb_supervisory-highlights_fall-2014.pdf* (similar); CFPB: Fall 2015 Supervisory Highlights, at 20-21, * available at https:// files.consumerfinance.gov/f/201510_cfpb_supervisory-highlights.pdf * (similar). B. Coverage This advisory opinion applies to debt collectors as defined in section 803(6) of the FDCPA and implemented in Regulation F, 12 CFR 1006.2(i). As used in this advisory opinion, pay-to-pay fees—sometimes called convenience fees—refers to fees incurred by consumers to make debt collection payments through a particular channel, such as over the telephone or online. C. Legal Analysis 1. Any Amount Section 808(1) of the FDCPA prohibits debt collectors, in relevant part, from “collect[ing] . . . *any* amount ( *including* any interest, fee, charge, or expense incidental to the principal obligation).” 14 As the Supreme Court has explained, the “word `any' has an expansive meaning, that is, `one or some indiscriminately of whatever kind.' ” 15 In addition, under its ordinary meaning, the term “including” typically indicates a partial list. 16 The CFPB interprets the words “any” and “including” as used in section 808(1) consistent with their ordinary meanings. Accordingly, the CFPB clarifies that FDCPA section 808(1) and Regulation F, 12 CFR 1006.22(b), apply to any amount collected by a debt collector in connection with the collection of a debt, 17 including, *but not limited to,* any interest, fee, charge, or expense that is incidental to the principal obligation. 14 15 U.S.C. 1692f(1) (emphasis added). *See also* 12 CFR 1006.22(b). 15 *Ali* v. *Fed. Bur. of Prisons,* 552 U.S. 214, 219

(2008)(quoting *United States* v. *Gonzales,* 520 U.S. 1, 5 (1997), in turn quoting Webster's Third New International Dictionary 97 (1976)). 16 *Include,* Black's Law Dictionary (11th ed. 2019). Additionally, as the Supreme Court has stated, “including” is “not [a term] of all-embracing definition, but connotes simply an illustrative application of the general principle.” *Fed. Land Bank of St. Paul* v. *Bismarck Lumber Co.,* 314 U.S. 95, 100 (1941); *see also Arizona State Bd. For Charter Schools* v. *Dep't of Educ.,* 464 F.3d 1003, 1007 (9th Cir. 2006) (“[T]he word `including' is ordinarily defined as a term of illustration, signifying that what follows is an example of the preceding principle.”); *United States* v. *Hawley,* 919 F.3d 252, 256 (4th Cir. 2019) (explaining that “including” “is an introductory term for an incomplete list of examples”). 17 The CFPB notes that, if a debt collector is engaged in a truly separate transaction and is not collecting or attempting to collect a debt covered by the FDCPA, section 808(1) does not apply. Consistent with this interpretation, the CFPB further clarifies that pay-to-pay fees charged to consumers for accepting a consumer's payment on a debt through a particular payment channel are an “amount” within the meaning of FDCPA section 808(1) and Regulation F, 12 CFR 1006.22(b). The CFPB acknowledges that some courts have held otherwise, finding that pay-to-pay fees do not violate FDCPA section 808(1) because such fees are not “incidental to the principal obligation.” 18 But, as explained, the CFPB interprets section 808(1) to apply to “any amount,” even if such amount is not “incidental to” the principal obligation. 19 18 *See, e.g.,* *Flores* v. *Collection Consultants of Cal.,* No. SA CV 14-0771-DOC, 2015 WL 4254032, at 10 (C.D. Cal. Mar. 20, 2015); *Shula* v. *Lawent,* 359 F.3d 489, 492-93 (7th Cir. 2004). In *Shula,* it does not appear that that court was presented with the question whether “any amount” included more than “fees . . . incidental to the principal obligation”; nor did that court analyze the issue. For the reasons stated above, the CFPB disagrees with that decision to the extent it suggested that section 808(1) applies only to amounts that are incidental to the principal obligation. 19 Section 808(1) of the FDCPA and Regulation F, 12 CFR 1006.22(b), also covers pay-to-pay fees for the separate reason that such fees are “incidental to” the principal obligation. While the FDCPA does not define “incidental,” it is ordinarily understood as “related to,” *see* Collins English Dictionary (12th ed. 2014), or “[s]ubordinate to something of greater importance,” *see* Black's Law Dictionary (11th ed. 2019). Pay-to-pay fees meet these definitions: They are “related to” the principal obligation because they are fees charged for paying the principal obligation. Indeed, if the principal obligation did not exist, then neither would the pay-to-pay fee. These fees are also generally minor in comparison to the outstanding debt and are therefore “subordinate to” the principal obligation. 2. Permitted by Law Section 808(1) of the FDCPA prohibits, in relevant part, the collection of any amount “unless such amount is expressly authorized by the agreement creating the debt or *permitted by law.”* 20 The word “permit” is susceptible to multiple meanings, but it tends to refer to “affirmative authorization,” and the CFPB reads section 808(1) to use the word in that sense. Dictionaries provide that “permit” can mean either “to consent to expressly or formally,” suggesting affirmative authorization, or to “allow” or “to acquiesce, by failure to prevent,” suggesting that the lack of a prohibition is sufficient. 21 However, “allow and permit have an important connotative difference. Allow . . . suggests merely the absence of opposition, or refraining from a proscription. In contrast, permit suggests affirmative sanction or approval.” 22 Use of the word “permit,” rather than “allow,” therefore suggests that affirmative authorization, rather than a mere lack of a prohibition, is required. Furthermore, as the Supreme Court has instructed, “words of a statute must be read in their context,” 23 and here, “permit” is used not in isolation but as part of the phrase “permitted by law.” While in some contexts one may “permit” something by failing to prevent it, it is far less natural to understand “permitted by law” to mean “permitted by the absence of any law prohibiting it.” 20 15 U.S.C. 1692f(1) (emphasis added). *See also* 12 CFR 1006.22(b). 21 *Permit,* Webster's Third New International Dictionary 1683 (1976); *see also Permit,* Black's Law Dictionary (5th ed. 1979) (defining “permit” as “[t]o suffer, allow, consent, let; to give leave or license; to acquiesce, by failure to prevent, or to expressly assent or agree to the doing of an act”). 22 Garner's Dictionary of Legal Usage 46 (3d ed. 2011); *see also Alexander* v. *Carrington Mortgage Services,* 23 F.4th 370, 377 (4th Cir. 2022) (holding “permitted by law” requires affirmative authorization). 23 *King* v. *Burwell* , 576 U.S. 473, 492 (2015). The CFPB therefore interprets FDCPA section 808(1) to prohibit a debt collector from collecting any amount unless such amount either is expressly authorized by the agreement creating the debt (and is not prohibited by law) or is expressly permitted by law. That is, the CFPB interprets FDCPA section 808(1) to permit collection of an amount only if:

(1)the agreement creating the debt expressly permits the charge and some law does not prohibit it; or

(2)some law expressly permits the charge, even if the agreement creating the debt is silent. The CFPB's interpretation of the phrase “permitted by law” applies to any “amount” covered under section 808(1), including pay-to-pay fees. 24 24 Note that, even if pay-to-pay fees are expressly authorized in the underlying agreement or permitted by State law, debt collectors must still take care to comply with other laws, including other provisions of the FDCPA and the Consumer Financial Protection Act's prohibition on unfair, deceptive, or abusive acts or practices, when assessing pay-to-pay fees. Under the CFPB's interpretation, an amount is impermissible if both the agreement creating the debt and other law are silent. For example, under the CFPB's interpretation, amounts, including pay-to-pay fees, that are neither expressly authorized by the agreement creating the debt nor expressly authorized by law are impermissible under FDCPA section 808(1) and Regulation F, 12 CFR 1006.22(b), even if such amounts are the subject of a separate, valid agreement under State contract law. 25 Although some courts have adopted this “separate agreement” interpretation to permit debt collectors to collect, for example, certain pay-to-pay fees, the CFPB declines to do so. Such a reading would render the part of section 808(1) that refers to amounts “expressly authorized by the agreement creating the debt” superfluous 26 because a lawful agreement creating the debt is, by definition, an agreement valid under State contract law. 27 In addition, the separate agreement interpretation ignores section 808(1)'s focus on the “amount” being “expressly authorized by the agreement creating the debt” or “permitted by law.” 28 Under section 808(1), it is not enough for the agreement to be “permitted by law”; rather, the “amount” itself must be. Contract law standing alone does not provide for the collection of any specific amounts—and no principle of contract law says debt collectors may collect pay-to-pay fees. 29 Thus, while it may have been permissible under contract law for a debt collector to enter into separate agreements with consumers, contract law does not permit the “amount” at issue, *i.e.,* the pay-to-pay fees. 25 The CFPB acknowledges that some district courts have held otherwise. *See, e.g.,* *Thomas-Lawson* v. *Carrington Mortg. Servs., LLC,* No. 2:20-cv-07301-ODW, 2021 WL 1253578 (C.D. Cal. Apr. 5, 2021), *appeal pending,* No. 21-55459 (9th Cir.). 26 *See Obduskey* v. *McCarthy & Holthus LLP,* 139 S. Ct. 1029, 1037

(2019)(refusing to interpret the FDCPA in a way that would render a provision “superfluous”). 27 *Accord Alexander,* 23 F.4th at 379 (rejecting the separate agreement interpretation in part because it would render section 808(1)'s other prong superfluous). The separate agreement interpretation also would conflict with the FDCPA's use of the phrase “expressly authorized,” since general principles of State contract law allow parties to agree to express or implied terms as part of any agreement. *See* Restatement (Second) of Contracts § 4 cmt. a (1981). If general principles of contract law counted as a “law” that “permitted” the collection of amounts, debt collectors would be free to collect not only those amounts authorized by separate agreements, but also to collect amounts that are only implicitly authorized by the agreement creating the debt—further rendering section 808(1)'s “express” requirement meaningless. 28 *See Johnson* v. *Riddle,* 305 F.3d 1107, 1118 (10th Cir. 2002) (“The statute does not ask whether [the debt collector's] actions were permitted by law . . . , it asks whether the *amount* he sought to collect was permitted by law.” (emphasis in original)). 29 While a *contract* might, consistent with contract law, permit an amount, section 808(1) only permits collecting amounts authorized *by contract* when the amount is expressly authorized by the contract “creating the debt.” The CFPB's interpretation of “permitted by law” in FDCPA section 808(1) is consistent with the previous interpretation in a CFPB compliance bulletin as discussed in part I.A., as well as with the prior interpretation of FTC staff and the holdings of the majority of courts to address the issue. 30 In particular, in 1988, FTC staff issued Commentary that set forth “staff interpretations” of the FDCPA. 31 As relevant here, FTC staff stated that, under section 808(1), a “debt collector may attempt to collect a fee or charge in addition to the debt if . . . the contract [creating the debt] is silent but the charge is otherwise expressly permitted by state law.” 32 Conversely, FTC staff stated that “a debt collector may not collect an additional amount if . . . the contract does not provide for collection of the amount and state law is silent.” 33 30 *See, e.g., Alexander,* 23 F.4th at 376-77 (holding, in a case regarding pay-to-pay fees, that “ 'permitted by law' requires affirmative sanction or approval”); *Seeger* v. *AFNI, Inc.,* 548 F.3d 1107, 1111, 1112 (7th Cir. 2008) (finding that, to be entitled to collect a fee, debt collectors “must show that the fee is either authorized by the governing contract or that it is permitted by Wisconsin law” and that, in that case, that neither an agreement nor a law expressly permitting a collection fee existed); *Tuttle* v. *Equifax Check,* 190 F.3d 9, 13 (2d Cir. 1999) (explaining that if “state law neither affirmatively permits nor expressly prohibits service charges, a service charge can be imposed only if the customer expressly agrees to it in the [underlying] contract”). 31 *See* Staff Commentary on the Fair Debt Collection Practices Act, 53 FR 50097, 50101 (Dec. 13, 1988). 32 *Id.* at 50108. 33 *Id.* The CFPB's interpretation is also consistent with the FDCPA's statutory purposes. As noted in part I.A, Congress passed the FDCPA because it found that existing laws and procedures, including at the state level, were inadequate to protect consumers. Given this concern, it would be particularly unnatural to understand “permitted by law” to mean “permitted because no law prohibits it.” Accordingly, the CFPB interprets FDCPA section 808(1) and Regulation F, 12 CFR 1006.22(b), to prohibit debt collectors from collecting any amount, including any pay-to-pay fee, not expressly authorized in the agreement creating the debt unless there is some law that affirmatively authorizes the collection of that amount. 3. Payment Processors Debt collectors may violate FDCPA section 808(1) and Regulation F, 12 CFR 1006.22(b), when using payment processors who charge consumers pay-to-pay fees. For instance, a debt collector collects an amount under section 808(1) at a minimum when a third-party payment processor collects a pay-to-pay fee from a consumer and remits to the debt collector any amount in connection with that fee, whether in installments or in a lump sum. 34 34 *See, e.g.,* Ballentine's Law Dictionary (3d ed. 2010) (defining “collect” as “to receive payment”); *cf.* 15 U.S.C. 1692a(6) (defining debt collector to include persons who “directly or indirectly” collect debts). II. Regulatory Matters This is an advisory opinion issued under the CFPB's authority to interpret the FDCPA, including under section 1022(b)(1) of the Consumer Financial Protection Act, which authorizes guidance as may be necessary or appropriate to enable the CFPB to administer and carry out the purposes and objectives of Federal consumer financial laws, such as the FDCPA. 35 35 12 U.S.C. 5512(b)(1); 5481(14); 5481(12)(H). An advisory opinion is a type of interpretive rule. As an interpretive rule, this advisory opinion is exempt from the notice-and-comment rulemaking requirements of the Administrative Procedure Act. 36 Because no notice of proposed rulemaking is required, the Regulatory Flexibility Act does not require an initial or final regulatory flexibility analysis. 37 The CFPB has also determined that this advisory opinion does not impose any new or revise any existing recordkeeping, reporting, or disclosure requirements on covered entities or members of the public that would be collections of information requiring approval by the Office of Management and Budget under the Paperwork Reduction Act. 38 36 5 U.S.C. 553(b). 37 5 U.S.C. 603(a), 604(a). 38 44 U.S.C. 3501-3521. Pursuant to the Congressional Review Act, 39 the CFPB will submit a report containing this advisory opinion and other required information to the United States Senate, the United States House of Representatives, and the Comptroller General of the United States prior to the opinion's published effective date. The Office of Information and Regulatory Affairs has designated this advisory opinion as not a “major rule” as defined by 5 U.S.C. 804(2). 39 5 U.S.C. 801 *et seq.* Rohit Chopra, Director, Consumer Financial Protection Bureau. [FR Doc. 2022-14230 Filed 7-1-22; 8:45 am]

Connectionstraces to 11

Traces to 11 documents

U.S. Code